Introduction:
The Deposition or Abdication Scene in Christopher Marlowe’s “Edward II” holds tremendous dramatic significance and offers a wealth of material for critical examination. This pivotal scene delves into the power struggle between King Edward II and his adversaries, particularly Young Mortimer and Queen Isabella. It explores themes of political ambition, the abuse of power, and the consequences that arise when personal desires clash with the responsibilities of rulership.
Critical Analysis:
Considered the pinnacle of Marlowe’s dramatic art in his historical tragedy, the Abdication or Deposition scene stands as one of the most remarkable passages in English dramatic literature. Set in the castle of Killingworth (Kenilworth), where the imprisoned king resides under the custody of the Duke of Leicester, this scene unfolds with gripping action, poetic language, and profound pathos.
The scene commences with Leicester imploring the king to find solace and security in his thoughts. Following this, King Edward II embarks on a poignant soliloquy, reflecting on his fallen state and the profound pathos of his royal downfall.
Enraged by the clandestine machinations of Mortimer and Isabella, the king vehemently expresses his determination to cling to his crown, refusing to yield it and make Mortimer the king of England.
The Bishop of Winchester, representing Mortimer and Isabella, along with the Duke of Leicester, beseech the king to surrender his crown. However, consumed by passion and rage, the king fiercely clings to the crown, reluctant to part with it. In impassioned and imaginative poetry, he fervently expresses his desire to retain the crown, donning it fondly.
The followers of Mortimer, anxious to secure the crown, resort to minimal words but threaten that the prince’s right may be jeopardized due to the king’s obstinacy.
Reluctantly, the king agrees to relinquish the crown, though his passion and resentment remain unabated. His abdication feels like an inescapable fate, and he transfers the crown with great reluctance.
As the Bishop of Winchester and others prepare to depart, the king presents them with a handkerchief soaked with his tears and dried by his sighs, intended for Isabella. The scene concludes with the arrival of Lord Berkeley, who arrives with an order from the queen. Under this order, the king is placed under Berkeley’s custody and departs with him.
Dramatic Significance:
The Abdication Scene serves as the epitome of Marlowe’s dramatic genius. Structurally, it marks the climax of the play, as the king is pressured to abdicate in favor of his son. Tormented by anguish, the unfortunate sovereign is compelled to relinquish that which he holds dearer than life itself. This scene completes the king’s downfall and sets the stage for the retribution against Mortimer.
Edward’s nature is vividly portrayed in this scene, infused with Marlowe’s characteristic poetry. The king speaks like a poet, drawing parallels to Shakespeare’s Richard II. He passionately dwells on his acute suffering and torment, reflecting on the greatness of his rank, which sets him above the average man, whether in adversity or prosperity. “The griefs of private men are soon allayed, but not of kings.”
With poetic vigor, the king contemplates the irony of his lot, a helpless captive in the hands of powerful nobles: “My noble rule, I bear the name of King; I wear the crown, but I am controlled by them.”
The scene effectively showcases Edward’s passionate nature, exemplified by his outbursts of anger, both violent and futile. His soliloquy, rich with poetic vigor, expresses his vehement passion. The mere thought of Young Mortimer irritates him and reinforces his resolve to keep the crown at all costs. As the crown is handed over to Mortimer’s followers, the king succumbs to another passionate outburst: “But stay a while, let me be the king till night. That I may gaze upon this glittering crown.”
This scene is instrumental in evoking sympathy and compassion for Edward. Although Marlowe’s portrayal of Edward falls short of the grandeur expected of a typical tragic hero, his weakness and pitiable fate invoke pity. The Abdication Scene effectively garners empathy, transforming the king’s faults and follies into elements of the past. Through poetry and passion, he becomes not only pathetic but also tragic. The scene doesn’t elicit the pity deserving of a tragic hero but engenders sympathy and awe for a character whose doom is implied in his very nature.
However, it is important to note that a discordant note emerges in the form of the handkerchief incident. This element, incongruous with the refined atmosphere, introduces an element of ridicule into an otherwise brilliant scene. It diminishes the tragic grandeur that Edward II’s character partially achieves in this scene.
Also Read :
- Compare Hamlet with Macbeth, Othello and other Tragedies
- “The Pardoner’s Tale” is the finest tale of Chaucer
- Prologue to Canterbury Tales – (Short Ques & Ans)
- Confessional Poetry – Definition & meaning
In summary,
the Deposition or Abdication Scene in “Edward II” holds immense dramatic significance within the play. It serves as the climax of the power struggle, showcases the consequences of personal desires clashing with the responsibilities of rulership, and raises important questions about the nature of power and the complexities of political ambition. Marlowe’s masterful construction of tension and exploration of psychological dynamics contribute to the enduring impact and critical analysis of this scene.
Conclusion:
The Deposition or Abdication Scene in Christopher Marlowe’s “Edward II” holds immense dramatic significance within the play. It serves as the climax of the power struggle, showcases the consequences of personal desires conflicting with the responsibilities of rulership, and raises important questions about power dynamics and the complexities of political ambition. Marlowe’s masterful construction of tension and exploration of psychological dynamics contribute to the enduring impact and critical analysis of this scene.
In conclusion, the Abdication Scene stands as a necessary prelude to the tragic end of the king. The custody of Edward is transferred from Leicester to Berkeley, as Mortimer aims to ensure a smooth and discreet execution of the king. This sets the stage for Mortimer’s tyrannical design.
PLEASE HELP ME TO REACH 1000 SUBSCRIBER ON MY COOKING YT CHANNEL (CLICK HERE)
